How to Choose Timesheet Software

Picking the wrong timesheet software wastes money and frustrates your team. Here's a practical framework for making the right choice.

Start With Your Actual Needs

Before looking at products, answer these questions:

1. How do your employees work? — Office-based, remote, field workers, or mixed?
2. What do you need to track? — Just hours worked, or also projects/tasks/clients?
3. Who approves timesheets? — One manager, multiple supervisors, or self-approval?
4. What's your payroll software? — This determines export requirements.
5. Do you also need leave management? — Some apps include it, others are timesheets-only.

Essential Features for UK Businesses

Questions to Ask Vendors

1. Where is my data stored? — For GDPR compliance, UK or EU servers are preferred.
2. What happens if I outgrow the plan? — Understand pricing at 20, 50, 100 employees.
3. Can I export my data if I leave? — Avoid vendor lock-in.
4. What support is included? — Email, chat, phone? What timezone?
5. How often do you update the product? — Active development matters.

Red Flags to Watch For

Find the Perfect Timesheet Solution

UK-built for UK businesses. Mobile apps, GDPR compliance, and payroll integration included. Free 14-day trial.

Start Free Trial

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: Buying Too Much

If you just need weekly timesheets and approval, don't pay for project management, GPS tracking, and detailed task breakdowns. More features means more complexity and higher cost.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Your Team

The fanciest software fails if employees won't use it. Test with real staff, not just managers. If it's confusing or slow, adoption will be poor.

Mistake 3: Forgetting About Growth

Check pricing at your expected team size in 2-3 years. Some apps are cheap at 5 users but expensive at 25.

Mistake 4: Not Testing the Export

Before committing, export test data to your actual payroll software. "Integrates with Xero" sometimes means "requires manual steps."

How to Run a Good Trial

1. Pick 3-5 employees across different roles — Include skeptics, not just early adopters.
2. Run a real payroll cycle — Submit, approve, export, process.
3. Test on mobile — Have remote workers try logging from their phones.
4. Time the process — How long do submissions and approvals take?
5. Gather feedback honestly — What's annoying? What's missing?

A 2-week trial is usually enough to know if it works for your team.

Try TimeTally Free for 14 Days

Mobile-first timesheets, one-click approvals, and payroll export in under 5 minutes. See why UK businesses choose TimeTally.

Start Free Trial