TimeTally vs Deputy

Deputy is a global scheduling-first platform starting at £1/user for scheduling-only — but leave management requires a higher-tier plan. TimeTally includes both timesheets and leave management at £2/employee/month, with UK compliance built in. No tiers, no add-ons.

No credit card required
£2/employee/month
All features included

Quick comparison

FeatureTimeTallyDeputy
Pricing£2 all-inclusiveFrom £1 (scheduling-only)
Leave management includedHigher tier only
Timesheet tracking
Shift schedulingCore feature
UK statutory entitlementBuilt-inConfigurable
Payroll exportXero/QuickBooks/CSVVarious integrations
iOS app
The Key Difference

All-inclusive vs scheduling-first pricing

Deputy is a US-headquartered global platform used across hospitality, retail, and healthcare. Its cheapest plan at £1/user covers scheduling only — leave management requires upgrading to a higher tier. TimeTally includes everything — timesheets with approval, full leave management, and payroll export to Xero, QuickBooks, or CSV — in a single £2/employee plan. Deputy's UK-specific compliance features are also less developed than its US features. See our comparison matrix for a full side-by-side view.

TimeTally timesheet entry form
Hours tracking
Holiday tracking
Approval workflow
Payroll export

Leave management included, not an upgrade

With Deputy, leave management is a separate, higher-tier module. With TimeTally, it's included from day one — no upgrades needed.

UK holiday entitlement

Auto-calculated based on working pattern and start date

Custom leave types

Sick leave, TOIL, compassionate leave, and more

TimeTally holiday requests
Timesheet tracking on mobile

UK-built timesheet tracking

Deputy is a global platform with strong scheduling features, but its UK-specific compliance is less developed than its US capabilities. TimeTally is built from the ground up for UK businesses — with automatic UK statutory entitlements, timesheet approval workflows, overtime calculations, and direct payroll export to UK-popular accounting software.

Hours tracking

Employees log start/end times or total hours per day

Timesheet approval

Managers approve or reject with one tap

Pricing breakdown

TimeTally

£2

per employee/month (all-inclusive)

  • Unlimited timesheets
  • Holiday management
  • Timesheet approval
  • Hours tracking
  • Payroll exports
  • Admin users free

Deputy

From £1

per user/month (scheduling-only)

  • Shift scheduling
  • Time & attendance
  • Shift swapping
  • Payroll integrations
  • Leave management costs extra
  • UK compliance less developed

Example:For 20 employees needing timesheets + leave, Deputy's higher-tier plan costs more per user. TimeTally for 20 employees = £40/month with everything included — no tier upgrades needed.

Everything flows to payroll

Timesheets, overtime, and holiday data all flow from one system — ensuring consistency and accuracy. Both TimeTally and Deputy offer payroll integrations, but TimeTally is specifically optimised for UK businesses using Xero and QuickBooks. Explore how it works or use our ROI calculator to see the savings.

  • Export approved hours to Xero or QuickBooks
  • Holiday taken automatically deducted
  • Overtime calculated and included
  • CSV and Excel formats available
Export to payroll

Which should you choose?

Choose Deputy if:

  • Shift scheduling is your top priority
  • You operate globally across multiple countries
  • You need advanced shift-swapping for hospitality or retail

Choose TimeTally if:

  • You need timesheets and leave in one plan
  • You want UK-built compliance from day one
  • You don't need shift scheduling but do need payroll export

Need global shift scheduling → Deputy
Need UK timesheets + leave, all-inclusive→ TimeTally

Try TimeTally free for 14 days

No credit card required. Get both timesheets and holidays in one simple tool.

No credit card required • Free 14-day trial • Cancel anytime